1. I notice some modules no longer are showing their Q&A. For example: https://www.magentocommerce.com/magento-connect/call-for-price-14.html merely shows and empty page 1. Could have sworn there were a bunch of questions there. Are module writers allow to remove or hide questions and answers? If yes this makes that tab almost worthless.
2. I can't seem to comment on a comment. For example I rated their terrible module (not it is not an actual module but some rather ugly hacks), they author commented, and I would like to reply, but apparently that functionality doesn't exist? Unless we can comment back that tab is almost worthless.
I understand wanting to give module writers a nice platform to show off their modules but if community members are unnecessarily limited in how we can rate them then we aren't able to tell what is actually a good module.
I ask that the site admins consider keeping Q&A and not allowing module writers to retroactively delete everything the community asked.
I ask that the site admins allow for us to comment on our own rating.
I wasted money and way too much time on a really terrible "module". Q&A and rating comments could improve magento commerce for us all.
Also when rating modules the Magento version numbers are out of date. For example I tested on 1.9.x but the drop down only goes to 1.8. That should be fixed else it breaks the usefulness of the drop down.
I hope Magento corp isn't abandoning the 1.9x community.
I attempted to post another review but it was rejected with out reason. They merely said to read the guidelines yet no specific issue was raised. I think allowing community members to honestly post on magento module rating system is important. Only posting positive reviews is bad for everybody.