cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Google reCAPTCHA broken after 2.3.1 >> 2.3.2 upgrade

Highlighted

Google reCAPTCHA broken after 2.3.1 >> 2.3.2 upgrade

After upgrade reCAPTCHA is not working correctly.  Configured as reCAPTCHA v2 in Magento. Worked without issue in 2.3.1 and config did not change.

 

Google reCAPTCHA account is configured properly (same keys) and config has not changed.

 

Issue: login page shows the expected "I'm not a robot" checkbox.  But, on the lower-right is a partial dialog that when you hover expands to "This site is not enabled for the invisible captcha."

 

Anyone else run into this or have ideas how to make it work like it did in 2.3.1?

 

problem1.jpg

13 REPLIES 13
Highlighted

Re: Google reCAPTCHA broken after 2.3.1 >> 2.3.2 upgrade

Hi,

 

Have you tried to re-enter in the recaptcha key in admin?

 

Also are there any error in the page source. Like javascript errors?

 

I havent used recaptcha myself, was considering it, but now this issue has been thinking twice

 

Regards

Brendan

Developer
Highlighted

Re: Google reCAPTCHA broken after 2.3.1 >> 2.3.2 upgrade

Hi 

 

Yes, we are seeing exactly the same issue.

In order to validate the issue we ran a clean new composer install of Magento 2.3.2 on Centos 7.6.1810/Apache 2.4.6/PHP 7.2.19.

Did not install anything except vanilla Magento 2.3.2.

Enabled ReCaptcha in backend with validated working keys, and immediately this message appeared on the frontend:

"The site key is not enabled for the invisible captcha"

It is a tab that is fixed to the bottom right of the screen !!!

Another thing is the captcha installed is not invisible, it standard v2 'I'm not a robot' captcha.

 

Magento send us these 'install immediately, critical security update....' warnings, but then break our site with the updates, 2.3.2 also breaks backups too !! 

Does nothing at all to inspire anyone to upgrade to Enterprise, why pay for bust apps ?

 

Highlighted

Re: Google reCAPTCHA broken after 2.3.1 >> 2.3.2 upgrade

So what's the next step? Do I bring up the issue in the git repository as a bug or is this forum as far as it goes?
Highlighted

Re: Google reCAPTCHA broken after 2.3.1 >> 2.3.2 upgrade

Hi Jon

We see this as a bug, it only started is 2.3.2.

Already been raised here: https://github.com/magento/magespecialist_ReCaptcha/issues/45

But the authors reply is somewhat non-plus.....  He suggests disabling it for the newsletter, and we confirm that works, but then leaves the newsletter signup open to attack , precisely what the captcha is designed to stop !

He provides another rather un-elegant suggestion to override some core file, this also works but them places the "I'm not a robot" box right next to the newsletter signup box which looks dreadful and overlays nearby content

Highlighted

Re: Google reCAPTCHA broken after 2.3.1 >> 2.3.2 upgrade

we also just upgraded from 2.3.1 to 2.3.2 and are having the same issue!

Highlighted

Re: Google reCAPTCHA broken after 2.3.1 >> 2.3.2 upgrade

Yes Simon, you're not alone !

We ended up taking the captcha off the newsletter signup and that fixed it.

Going forward, ff the newsletter gets spammed we'll just disable it

Highlighted

Re: Google reCAPTCHA broken after 2.3.1 >> 2.3.2 upgrade

Is the etiquette here to mark this accepted solution or because there is an open defect I leave it open?

Highlighted

Re: Google reCAPTCHA broken after 2.3.1 >> 2.3.2 upgrade

Hi Jon

 

To be honest I'm not sure, but thanks for asking

Highlighted

Re: Google reCAPTCHA broken after 2.3.1 >> 2.3.2 upgrade

I noticed the same message (but already on my main page) after upgrading.

 

I generated a v3 captcha key instead of my old v2 key.

 

"only" problem now is an ugly recaptcha icon on the site, that is VERY intrusive when you visit the site using a mobile phone.